How to Use Your Email List Effectively | BookTix Best Practices

How to Use Your Email List Effectively

⏱︎ 2 minutes

Why Email Still Works

We’ve all been there, with our inboxes overflowing with emails from companies we don’t remember signing up for. Most of them get ignored or deleted. And yet, email remains one of the most powerful marketing tools available. Why?

  • Because when it’s targeted, timed, and crafted with empathy, email works.

  • You’re not just selling a ticket or asking for a donation, you’re building a relationship.

How To Use Your Lists

Step 1: Understand the Psychology of Your Audience  

People open emails when they:
  • Feel like it’s for them (personalization matters!)
  • Trust the sender

  • Feel urgency or curiosity

  • See clear value

Avoid: Overloading your emails with too many asks, irrelevant content, or general, vague messages.

Step 2: Get the Timing Right  

Timing is everything. Here’s a sample email timeline for a show:

When

Email Focus

2–3 months before

Announcement – Save the date, teaser trailer, early access.

3–4 weeks before

Reminder + Value Add – Offer a perk (early bird price, free concession).

1 week before

Urgency – Highlight limited seating, special guests, etc.

2–3 days before

Final Reminder – “Happening this weekend!”

Night before

Immediate Action – “Starts tomorrow—get your tickets now!”

Day after

Thank You – And promote the next thing.

Ongoing

Segmented Follow-Ups – Ask for donations, invite to VIP, share behind-the-scenes content.

Step 3: Segment Your List 

Stop sending the same message to everyone. Instead:
  • Past Ticket Buyers : Invite back with exclusive offers.

  • Big Donors :  Don't ask them to buy tickets—thank them, offer VIP access.

  • Never-Opened Emails : Re-engage with curiosity-based subject lines.

A generic email feels like spam. A segmented email feels like an invitation.

Step 4: Craft Clear, Compelling Messaging  

Each email should have:
  • One clear focus 

  • A strong subject line – Test different versions (A/B testing)

  • Compelling visualsUse clean design and avoid clutter

  • Short, engaging copy – People skim!

  • A clear Call to Action – e.g., “Buy Tickets Now” or “Donate Today”

Avoid burying your Call to Action. Place it prominently near the top and again at the bottom.

Step 5: Use A/B Testing and Analytics  

Track what’s working. Try A/B testing:
  • Subject lines

  • Send times

  • CTA wording

  • Layout styles

Metrics to monitor:

  • Open rate

  • Click-through rate (CTR)

  • Unsubscribe rate (a red flag)

Step 6: Make Them Feel Special  

Email should feel like:
  • A personal invite, not a broadcast

  • A message from a club they’re part of, not a company

  • Something they’d miss if they didn’t get it

Try:

  • Behind-the-scenes sneak peeks

  • Early access to events

  • Quotes from other attendees

  • Special thank-you emails

  • Personalized “We miss you” emails for lapsed patrons

Step 7: Offer Value and Urgency  

People act when:
  • They get something in return (bonus, experience, discount)

  • They know time is limited

Examples:

  • “Buy by Friday for a free drink ticket”

  • “Only 12 seats left in the VIP section”

  • “This offer ends at midnight”

Step 8: Don’t Just Sell the Show — Tell the Story  

People won’t buy based on the title alone.
Bad example:
Subject: “Tickets on sale for Under the Moonlight”
Better example:
Subject: “A love story unfolds in 'Under the Moonlight' — opening soon!”
Explain:
  • What’s the show about?
  • Why are you excited?
  • Why is it worth their time and money?

Email Checklist Before Sending  

✔ Segmented to the right audience
✔ Strong subject line
✔ One clear message
✔ Call to action is easy to find
✔ Visuals are clean and on-brand
✔ Value is obvious
✔ Sent at the right time
✔ Tracking is in place

Build a Loyal Audience, Not Just One-Time Buyers  

Email isn't just about pushing promotions. It's about building loyalty and connection.
You want your audience to think:
“I can’t wait to see what’s next from them.”
And that only happens when:
  • You know who they are
  • You respect their time
  • You provide consistent value
    • Related Articles

    • Understanding the Email Marketing Tool

      ⏱︎ 2 minutes What is the Email Marketing Tool? The email marketing tool lets you create and send custom email campaigns, design customized layouts, and track performance with built-in analytics, all from within your BookTix account. IMPORTANT NOTE: ...
    • All About the Email Marketing Tool

      ⏱︎ 2 minutes The email marketing tool lets you create and send custom email campaigns, design customized layouts, and track performance with built-in analytics, all from within your BookTix account. This article will link you through all of the steps ...
    • Building a List - Upload Custom List

      ⏱︎ 2 minutes There are 3 ways to build a List - Purchase History (based on orders made across both log in accounts or guest account), Customer Profiles (based on traits within login accounts only), or Upload a Custom List (where you can import your ...
    • Understanding Your List Summary

      ⏱︎ 2 minutes Use this article to understand your list's details, data summaries, the filters utilized, and the functions you can use. 1. Access the List Builder. 2. Click on the List you wish to view. 3. Find your list. Filters and List Summary ...
    • Email Campaign Ideas

      ⏱︎ 3 minutes There’s a reason our inboxes are constantly flooded with emails; brands and organizations know that email is one of the most effective tools to capture attention and drive action. Whether it’s a Labor Day sale, Black Friday deal, or ...